Cannabis vs. alcohol: it isn't close.
Compare them on toxicity, dependence, organ harm, and deaths, and you'll see why so many people are swapping the bottle for the plant.
The head-to-head
| Measure | Alcohol | Cannabis |
|---|---|---|
| Toxicity (margin of exposure) | "High risk": at the population level, the only substance in the high-risk band1 | Population MOE above 10,000, the lowest risk of every drug studied1 |
| Overall harm (expert ranking) | Ranked #1 most harmful drug overall (score 72), and the most harmful to other people2 | Not in the top three. Alcohol (72) scored above heroin (55) and crack cocaine (54)2 |
| Chance of dependence after first use | 22.7% lifetime8 | 8.9% lifetime8 |
| U.S. deaths | About 178,000 per year, cutting an average of 24 years off each life3 4 | The National Academies found insufficient evidence of any link between cannabis and overdose death11 |
| Cancer | A causal link to at least 7 cancers, including breast, colorectal, liver, mouth, and throat, per the U.S. Surgeon General7 | Moderate evidence of no association between smoking cannabis and lung or head-and-neck cancers11 |
| Global toll | 2.6 million deaths worldwide in 2019 (4.7% of all deaths)5 | Lowest toxicological risk of the drugs compared1 |
| Safe amount | The Global Burden of Disease study found the level of drinking that minimizes health loss is zero6 | Has FDA-approved medicines and a federal finding of accepted medical use21 55 |
Lifetime chance of becoming dependent after first use
Toxicity: margin of exposure (higher = safer)
Swapping the bottle for the plant
Evan's story isn't unique. Researchers have been documenting it for years.
fewer drinks on cannabis days among heavy drinkers in treatment, who were also about half as likely to binge15
of Canadian medical-cannabis patients drank less often after starting cannabis, and 8% quit alcohol entirely14
of patients in Canada's federal medical-cannabis program reported substituting cannabis for alcohol52
less alcohol consumed after smoking 7.2% THC cannabis than after a placebo, in the first randomized trial of its kind (19% less at 3.1% THC)86
lower alcohol sales in counties in states with medical marijuana laws, based on store scanner data87
The Exit Drug: all the alcohol and opioid substitution research in one place.
Read it →